Been a while since I wrote a blog on this site!
But when I took a look at this male feminist BS ‘article’ I felt a very strong need to respond. This article is so bad that I took the time to archive it because I didn’t want the writer of this piece gaining any more positive hits for it if you have to read it
I did a YouTube response to this ‘article’ I use that term very lightly. I did a response to this article at YouTube which is below
I did find a brilliant response to this article at the Jordan B Peterson Liberal discussion group on Facebook. Which at least for now hasn’t been taken down by Big Brother yet
Gus Barkley wrote a brilliant response that sums it up better than I could. In fact, it’s so brilliant I’m republishing it here so we can all enjoy it. Not just the people at the Jordan B Peterson group. Gus if you read this, yes this is absolutely incredible! I don’t know if this is something you do all the time or if this is just a one-off. Good job so here in Gus’s own words is his response to this terrible article
7 Reasons Why Patriarchy Is Bad (and Feminism is Good) for Men
Just going to skip ahead to where Gus’s response. There are a couple of intro paragraphs that I have a response to in my YouTube response.
As we’ve talked about in other articles on TBINAA, there are certain aspects to the norms of masculinity that make men feel uncomfortable exploring certain parts of their own lives, minds, and personalities. A big aspect of upholding the norms of masculinity is that men often don’t put too much effort into questioning or reflecting on such norms, let alone how their own actions affect others. Rather than admitting faults or embracing vulnerability, men are told to “man up” or “stop being a p*ssy” in order to protect their precious masculinity, even if it means upholding harmful, destructive, and hate-filled norms that negatively affect those around them and, inevitably, themselves.
Feminism turns that idea of avoiding reflectiveness on its head. What many feminist leaders advocate for is that all people, especially men, be more reflective and introspective, and to be more comfortable with being called out for things that others may have an issue with. A big part of feminism is understanding how one’s actions and beliefs affect others, which patriarchal masculinity systematically avoids by upholding a more individualistic/man-vs-the world mentality. This aspect of feminism, especially as it has evolved in recent years, can help men understand that keeping up a persona of ultra-masculinity or machismo is something that not only make others uncomfortable, it can directly hurt those they love or care about the most.
It is false to equate telling someone to “man up,” or “stop being such a pussy,” with suggesting that the man in question not be introspective. Rather, it is asking him to overcome what is for some people an inclination to give in to unreasonable fear or pain, and to accept responsibility for doing what needs to be done. For example, imagine a father of a small child who panics when his child is injured and sits there sobbing instead of taking the child for the help he needs. “Man up,” you might say. “Don’t be such a pussy. Do what needs to be done and get some help for your child.” This has nothing to do with being introspective or not.
One of the most negative aspects of the patriarchal norms of masculinity is the tendency for men to constantly be in competition with each other. Almost every aspect of many men’s lives is shrouded by the need to see themselves as better than other men, or other people in general. This includes physically, such as working out for the specific intent of having bigger muscles, better abs, or more strength than other men, or intellectually, where men will feel the need to “mansplain” a topic to women, even if the women they’re talking to are more knowledgeable on the topic than they are. So much of the actions men take and the way men think are related to the desire to be better than others.
It’s a much different story in the world of feminism. Despite the many stereotypes of women being overly competitive with each other, feminism has been developed around the notion of community and solidarity being pertinent aspects of achieving self-love and self-care. It is much more important for feminists to create a strong community of like-minded and caring individuals than it is to automatically push away or compete with others. Feminists are much more interested in creating a space that feels safe and comfortable for as many people as possible. This can be beneficial for many men who have trouble simply accepting others in their lives without feeling the need to be better than them—they can find a way to truly separate themselves from the competition that surrounds them every day.
There is always going to be competition among people and there will always be cooperation. The issue is the right balance. Some men are too competitive, and so are some women, and so they see every interaction as a zero-sum game when most interactions are not. Some are not competitive enough and so they achieve much less than what they are capable of. Take team sports: The two teams compete to bring out the best in each other, but within the team, there needs to be cooperation for the team to succeed. But even within the team the players compete with each other for starting roles and playing time. This competition drives them to excel. This is a good thing. Sorry if I mansplained that to you.
It’s human nature for people to not like change. We like to be comfortable in whatever situation we find ourselves in, and we don’t like it when something comes along and puts us out of that comfort zone. We will find a way to stay comfortable, often at any and all costs. Unfortunately, this is exactly what patriarchy does for men. It enables men to remain comfortable in their privileges, in their dominance, in their reverence, while never having to question the issues women and nonbinary people have to deal with in relation to their comfort. For men, it’s easier to find partners who will do all of the things that men “aren’t supposed to do.” Although times have changed, many men still feel as though they are meant to be the main moneymakers in their household, while their partners should be the ones staying home, making them dinner, doing their laundry, taking care of their children, etc.
Feminism seeks to get rid of those archaic notions of what it means to be a “real man” or a “real woman.” Feminists would rather dismantle those norms and create a society that doesn’t let gender or whatever body parts you have dictate how people should or shouldn’t act.
What men don’t realize is that allowing themselves to fall into the trap of patriarchal masculinity is not only hurting the people they wish to be involved with in life, it’s hurting themselves by feeling as though they can’t truly explore themselves and understand that there’s more to life than keeping up with the status quo of gender.
What many feminists would rather see is men working alongside them to break down those barriers and norms and embrace a life of self-actualization that is free of baseless categorizations and judgments.
“Feminists would rather dismantle those norms and create a society that doesn’t let gender or whatever body parts you have dictate how people should or shouldn’t act.” Let’s start with why those norms exist. Women must bear the children. Women on average are so much better at nurturing young children than are men. Left to their own choices, women are much more likely to want to work with small children as daycare workers or elementary school teachers. This is true in every society throughout all of history, and is still true today in modern sex-egalitarian societies such as Scandinavia. Women typically don’t desire dangerous or physically taxing occupations. Women prefer to work part-time much more than do men. The list of sex differences across all cultures and epochs is fairly consistent.
Similar to the notion of keeping up the status quo, men often don’t realize how our society is built to put them ahead of women and nonbinary people. The patriarchy has supported this notion that men are inherently better than others, simply by virtue of being a man. Even if you identify as a man, if you don’t play along with the norms of masculinity, you’re treated as an “other” as well. More importantly, though, we see where men are put on a pedestal while others fall by the wayside. Typically, men are paid more, men are offered jobs more often, men pay less for products, men aren’t subjected to constant catcalling or sexual violence, men don’t have to face their insecurities, and men are happy about that. Unfortunately, women and nonbinary folks usually don’t have those same options, and they’re forced to be uncomfortable, feel unsafe, or face violence on a daily basis.
The solution that feminism has developed for this is leveling the playing field. That doesn’t mean men should have to deal with the same disadvantages as other people, rather men should both understand what others go through on a daily basis and also work toward eradicating those issues on their end, since much of it is perpetuated by men in the first place. Feminists strive first and foremost for equality, as well as healthy interpersonal relations. While striving for equality and giving up power and hierarchy sounds scary for a lot men, it actually presents an opportunity for men to put their effort into creating a society where women and nonbinary people don’t automatically fear men, especially cis men.
“Men don’t have to face their feelings.” Says who? Perhaps men face their feelings but, being governed less by those feelings than women, are able to act without always giving in to those feelings. For example, a man may be desperately afraid but still go into battle or chase down a dangerous criminal. Overcoming “feelings” is not the same thing as refusing to face those feelings. Perhaps men are not as vulnerable to sexual violence, but they are much more likely to be the victims of other sorts of violence. Men are much more likely to be murdered, beaten, etc. It’s crazy to say that men are put on pedestals. Men are criticized all day and every day in our current social environment. This article, for example.
Although the patriarchy benefits all men in one way or another, it doesn’t support all men in the same ways. This is one of the illusions the patriarchy tries to pull though: you’re a man, you’re better than women, and definitely better than nonbinary people. But what if you’re a black man as opposed to a white man? Or a poor man as opposed to a rich man? A trans man, a disabled man, an immigrant man, or an uneducated man as opposed to a cis man, an able-bodied man, a male citizen, or an educated man? What the patriarchy wants men to believe is that these other factors of race, ability, class, etc., don’t matter, that all men are equal, while it also supports the systems that oppress people who aren’t white, or rich, or able-bodied, or cisgender, or any combination of traits that are considered the “norm.”
Feminism, especially more recently, is focused on looking at everyone’s experiences through a lens of intersectionality. This means that as opposed to just looking at someone as a man, they recognize that man as also being black, disabled, and poor, for example. Intersectional feminism allows for a multi-faceted analysis of the various experiences, histories, and biases that affect a person. While the focus of feminism is primarily on gender, feminism with an emphasis on intersectionality can help men, women, and nonbinary folks alike understand where they are most negatively affected, how they experience various forms of oppression, and what they can do to eradicate those oppressive systems.
“Intersectionality” supposedly requires us to look at a person and to identify all of his identities that lead to his oppression. But this is evaluating a person based on his group characteristics, and not by his personal circumstances, which is the dictionary definition of prejudice. Not all women, all black people, or all gay people are oppressed, and not all straight white men lead a life of privilege. Some of the latter are poor, mentally challenged, in chronic pain, and lonely. Intersectionality is just a half-assed attempt to recognize that people are different, but it stops at group differences instead of individual differences.
There is no logical or reasonable way to deny that we live in a society that perpetuates rape and rape culture. Our society has been historically set up in a way that makes rape, sexual violence, or romantic manipulation not only possible, but rather a normal, expected occurrence for many people. For men, it is seen as a necessity to seduce women (or other potential sexual partners) to the point that they’re encouraged to force other people into sex, with little to no regard for consent. When men are questioned about it, it often gets played of as “boys will be boys,” or “uncontrollable sexual urges,” or “nothing that serious.” For the victim, however, they are often treated horribly, with outsiders calling them “sluts,” saying “they deserved it” or they were “asking for it” for one reason or another, and inevitably removing responsibility from the man who committed the act in the first place. And it goes beyond direct physical encounters too of course, with how women are objectified in every form of media, or how children and teenagers are sexualized to the point that they’re kicked out of class for clothing that’s deemed “too sexy,” so on and so forth.
Much of the recent focus of feminism is completely ridding our society of rape and rape culture. Feminism is focused on changing the conversation of “no means no” to “yes means yes,” providing services for women and other folks who have been affected by rape or sexual violence, and by looking at the very systems that exist to perpetuate the notion that rape is an expected and nearly acceptable occurrence. Feminism is out to protect everyone from the terrifying outcomes of rape and rape culture by making sure it can not only be talked about more openly, but it can also be more openly villainized and dismantled. Ultimately, that means breaking the patterns that lead men to think that manipulating, hurting, or raping women and other folks is okay and having men look at their actions and understand why a lot of people just don’t trust men in many situations.
Women are “sexualized” by the culture, but they are also kicked out of class for wearing clothing that is “too sexy.” Can’t you see the contradiction? Women want to be sexually alluring. They spend enormous amounts of time and money to make themselves alluring. This does not mean that they are inviting rape. But they are inviting male attention. The percentage of men who would commit rape is very small. Most are committed by the same few men. It is defamatory to suggest that rape is an epidemic among ordinary men. This is why we get the unbelievable statistics of 1 in 4 women on college campuses being raped. If this were true no reasonable woman would go to college. And if she did, she certainly wouldn’t go to drunken fraternity parties where she is most likely to be taken advantage of.
What all of this comes down to is the simple fact that the masculinity that patriarchy has bred and enabled is extremely toxic. It makes everything worse not only for those who are subjected to all of its negativity, hatred, subordination, and oppression, but it also makes things worse the men who benefit from it because they don’t have to question it.
Men are hurt by their own dedication to toxic, patriarchal masculinity by allowing themselves to hurt others.
While some men have definitely distanced themselves from the toxicity, most men are just fine staying in the positions and they’ll defend it no matter what, because they’re comfortable and safe. And just distancing themselves from toxic masculinity isn’t enough; men have to work to actually change their behaviors, and call out other men who are acting in toxic and horrible ways, who are acting in ways characterized by body terrorism.
This is one of the goals of feminism: to enable men to be less toxic and be more caring and supportive, to be willing to share and create safe spaces. But feminism is also important for men to achieve a level of radical self-love that patriarchy doesn’t allow in any way.
Men have to be more willing to understand themselves, their feelings, their insecurities, their needs, while also actively rejecting the notion that being violent or abusive or overbearing or condescending is normal. Men have to understand that you can’t separate gender from race, sexuality, ability, class, etc. Men have to be more feminist-minded when it comes to treating others with respect, with calling out toxicity, with fighting for social justice and equality, and with being good to themselves as well as those around them. It is pertinent to the betterment of our society that we can question ourselves, masculinity, and patriarchy.
Masculinity is bad. Men are bad. If you don’t agree you are supporting the patriarchy. Who knew?
Having had to endure reading this ‘article’ there’s really no other thing for me to conclude that this is a propaganda piece that was written by a male feminist. What you’re seeing here is an attempt by feminists to try and get ahead of the Men’s Rights Movement when it comes to Men’s issues. I’ve been seeing and reading articles like this in increasing numbers. Much like how the Regressive left is using increasingly desperate tactics to censor their opposition on social media. What you’re seeing from Feminism specifically is that they’re using their willing male allies attempting to establish the rapidly incoming narrative from the manosphere. They know that their attempts at intimidation and censorship are starting to fail.
If you think I’m just reaching here I was able to find this little piece on Phillipe Leonard Fradet
I’m going to just say it though, nobody and I do mean nobody outside the SJW/Feminist echo chamber is going to buy this.
Although Philippe do tell, what’s it like being so hard up for female approval that you would throw other men under the bus to get it? Masculinity is not a disease that needs to be cured.